The Things I Have Seen #7 (August 2011)
-One moment towards the end of Cowboys & Aliens summed it up for me. I hope it won’t give too much away to say there are also Native American Indians represented in the movie, and thankfully the Cowboys team up with them instead of just killing all non-Cowboys in sight. When the groups team up, or shortly thereafter, Harrison Ford shares a look with and nods at one of the Native American Indians – implying “we’re in this together,” tugging at the heartstrings and rewriting American history when it comes to Manifest Destiny and the dire fate of many of our country’s native peoples. It was a moment designed to fill a space, somewhat inspired but overwrought and not entirely well thought out and if that’s a metacomment on the film itself it’s probably by accident.
-I so enjoyed last month’s escape into the Harry Potter franchise that I rewatched all but the last one again. That should hold me.
-Ah, yes. The Millennium Trilogy. I borrowed the first two books of the series, The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, and The Girl Who Played With Fire, from a coworker at a job that no longer exists. I’ve had those for a year and reading the first one will forever remind me of the summer of 2010, fresh off the job, getting sun for the first time in years, trying to read more than I recently had to stretch out my attention span. That it took a full year for me to finish the books says less about my attention span (still not great) than about the books themselves: Overlong treatises on the tyranny of evil men, full of political intrigue and a journalistic level of detail crafted by the journalist author, the late Stieg Larsson. If the purpose of art truly is to hold a mirror up to nature, then nature feels endless and pointless and nearly entirely without meaning, the only recognizable thread of narrative buried so deep under piles of impractical details, so slowly discovered and difficult to find and follow that merely getting to the end is the accomplishment, the enjoyment of it hardly worth addressing. In that case, maybe as art the books do their job, but as books I just didn’t like them.
I did enjoy the mystery of the first, and the revealing backstory of the second and third, so I thought the Swedish versions of each of the films would be ideal. The inessential would be hacked away and the story alone would be left to enjoy apace. Well, like a rushed haircut, they took too much off the top. I figured you’d have to have read the books to know why any of this was important and how people truly felt, because the actions in the movie were nearly all actions, performed without most of the rising and falling emotions that pull a reader or viewer through the experience. At least the first had a mystery to dive into; the last two were buildup to a release that, while nearly worth my yearlong wait in the books, was on film over way too quickly.
Noomi Rapace plays the definitive Lisbeth Salander in a series of productions where she is the most convincing part: Good for her, but she so outpaced every other aspect of the production it was unfair. I’m looking forward to David Fincher’s versions, to see how he and the writers parsed all this material. But for these versions, I spent far too much time wondering why I was watching these in the first place. Then I remembered it was only to have watched them, maybe the poorest reason of all, and the most insulting, and the least worthwhile.




